FEED TRIALS – RESULTS, IMPLICATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
North Queensland Crayfish farmers Association – 2016
Following conclusion of the Feed and Nutrition Project in December 2015 by James Cook University, it became the responsibility of QCFA to do what was necessary to implement the results and facilitate how the industry could maximise the benefit of the research. The obvious answer was to deliver the new feed to the redclaw in the most beneficial way. This meant making a pellet that had good water stability and was physically sound while complying with the specified protein and energy requirement. Trials were conducted over a period of six months and the best decision made based on the results.
The formulae for the new feed allows for 26% protein for adult feed and 28% for juveniles as recommended by the JCU Feed and Nutrition research project. It also contains a binder to help water stability and a specific Crustacean Vitamin and Mineral Premix. The diet is vegetable based, containing no meat or seafood products, also as a result of the research project findings.
TRIAL DATA and RESULTS:
Cost implications of ingredient variations:
Replacement of 25% of wheat with Flour – + $60/t
Replacement of 50% of wheat with flour – +$120/t
Oil coating (used for energy in pig feed) +$9/t
Salvetti full fat soy 100% + $155/t
Mastercube binder + $5/t per 1kg binder added
All batches have been made to the 26% protein level recommended by JCU
Batch 1 – 9/3/16 – 15 days after die change (est)
Supplied to Colin
5kg Mastercube added
Zero fines – swollen but intact after 3 hours – good stability
Batch 2 – 4/5/16 – 14 days after die change
Supplied to Klaus
3kg Mastercube added
Zero fines – slight disintegration after 2 hours – fair stability
Batch 3 – 4/5/16 – 14 days after die change
Supplied to NQCFA – Distributed to members
5kg Mastercube added
25% of wheat substituted with flour
1.3% fines – swollen but intact after 3 hours– good stability
Batch 4 – 14/6/16 – 27 days after die change
10kg alternative binder added without consultation
3.4% fines – disintegration in 30 minutes – failed stability trial
Alternative binder useless – batch destroyed
Batch 5 – 1/7/16 – 15 days after die change
Supplied to Beldans
100% Salvetti full fat soy
18% fines – Disintegration started inside 1 hour – unacceptable
Batch 6 –1/7/16 – 15 days after die change
Supplied to Colin (bulk)
50% Salvetti full fat soy
6% fines – Disintegration began immediately – unacceptable
Batch 7 –1/7/16 – 15 days after die change
Supplied to Joe
100% USA soy
3% fines – Disintegration began after 1 hour – barely acceptable
Batch 8 – 14/7/16 – 28 days after die change
Supplied to Klaus
5.7% fines – moderate disintegration after 4 hours – barely acceptable
Batch 9 / 10 – 25/7/16 – 3 days after die change
Supplied to Mick and Bill Keast
Standard 5k Mastercube
1.3% fines – Swollen but intact after 2 hours – fair stability
Batch 11 – 8/10 – 2 days after die change
50% wheat substituted as flour
3.8% fines – excellent stability
Batch 12 – 8/10 – 2 days after die change
juvenile feed – 28% protein
`0.3% fines – fair stability
|QCFA FEED IMPLEMENTATION TRIALS – February to July 2016|
|Days after new die||Immersion hours|
|Gymp||MDS you very much||MoD||D||R|
Standard Diet – 26% protein – 5kg Mastercube
Cost is ex-mill – 25kg QCFA bags – plus 4% levy + GST
SNB Swollen not broken
MBS Minor breaks with stick agitation
MDS Minor disintegration with stick agitation
MoD Moderate disintegration with stick agitation
D Completely disintegrated
R Rubble – trial terminated
Pellet quality was judged by the fines content and general condition of the feed. “Fines” are defined as particles that fell through a 3mm sieve.
The above results display a marked relationship in quality (% fines) to the number of days following a die change when ingredients are similar.
The results indicate the pellet quality problem lies mostly with the condition of the die, rather than the content of the pellets.
The results of physical damage deliberately inflicted on the pellets, indicates that the fines are not the result of pellet crumbling, but that they have never in fact been pelletised
Inquiries with the mill have found that the die routinely lasts around four weeks. The ‘days after die change’ figures have been split into calendar and week days to negate the effect of weekends and holidays
The integrity of batch 4 was compromised because the mill substituted an alternate binder for Mastercube without consultation. Batch 4 plays no part in the comparison. This batch was made right at the end of the die life and it is not known for sure whether the total unacceptably of this batch was because of the binder or the die condition or both.
Batches 5 and 6 were trials of using local Full Fat Soy meal in place of imported soy meal at midrange die life and were unacceptably high in fines
Batches 5 to 7 were made in a 24 hour period so their comparative results are not influenced by die life even though the percentage of fines varied widely, indicating that composition as well as die life are factors in pellet quality.
Batch 8 was made right at the end of the die life and certainly displays high fines percentage
Batches 9 and 10 were made immediately after a die change and have an acceptable level of fines. Batch 9 contained an unexplainable content of whole sorghum which caused the pellets containing it to break readily.
Batch 11 was made 2 days after die change and with flour substituted for 50% of the wheat content. The fines content was unexplainably high considering that Batch 12 was made the same day and showed excellent fines level.
Water stability was assessed by immersing pellets in a shallow dish of water and recording their condition at hourly intervals up to 4 hours. Pellets were moved around gently with a paddle pop stick at each assessment to simulate movement by grazing redclaw. Six levels of pellet condition were established:
Swollen not Broken (SNB) means the pellets absorbed water but did not lose their form.
Minor Breaks means that the pellets broke into 2 whole pieces
Minor Disintegration means that some particles were leaving the pellet
Moderate Disintegration means a significant number of particles were leaving the pellet.
Disintegrated means the feed was no longer in a pellet form
Rubble means that the feed had turned to mush and was no longer readily available to redclaw.
The water stability of batches 1, 2, 3, 9 and 10 were reasonably consistent. After 4 hours immersion, pellets were still in a form to be available to redclaw and withstood gentle movement with an implement. Batch 11 did show the best water stability.
Batch 3 was used as a control throughout the trials and showed consistent results. Interestingly, at the end of the 7 month trial period the stability of this control batch proved better than when first made
Batches 5, 6 and 7 were made on the same day with variations in in ingredients. Contrary to expectations, the Full Fat Soy Meal batches 5&6 displayed very poor water stability. Double the amount of Mastercube binder in batch 7 also yielded poor stability. It is hard not to consider some unknown factor influenced these results given that they were made together, but no evidence of anything to substantiate this was found. It can only be deduced that the die age was the common contributing factor.
Batch 8 was made at the limit of die life and predictably displayed less than ideal water stability.
Batches 9 and 10 were made with a new die. Batch 10 was a repeat of batch 9 due to its sorghum content. The pellets in batch 9 that did not contain sorghum were unaffected.
Batch 11 with 50% wheat content as flour was the best performing batch of the trial.
Batch 12 was the juvenile formulation with 28% protein. it show water stability charactistics the same as other standard batches
The bagged price of the “old” feed was $670 per tonne. The bagged price of the “new” feed in standard form is $750 per tonne. The additional cost is due to the increased protein percentage and binder. The bagged price of the batches trialled with 25% and 50% of the wheat content substituted as flour were $814 and $878 per tonne respectively. The juvenile feed price is $770 per tonne due to the higher protein level. In all cases, bagged feed is $40 per tonne dearer than bulk ex-mill. Prices are from Advanced Rural mill Tolga NQ.
The prices are plus 4% QCFA Research Levy plus GST
These prices are all within the guidelines set by farmers at an NQCFA meeting.
It is strongly recommended that farmers enquire with the mill regarding the date of die changes when ordering feed. Results show that it is advisable the feed be made within a 10 working day period following die change.
The decision of which formulation will be adopted as the standard “Redclaw Feed”, has to be a balance of quality and cost. This is a farmer’s decision, not a researcher’s, and will be decided at an Association meeting.
- Die life is not the only governing factor in producing a pellet with acceptable physical properties and water stability. However it is the major contributing factor and can be managed.
- After exhaustive trials with eleven combinations of ingredients, the formulation including 5kg Mastercube binder per tonne proved to be acceptable. The addition of 25 and 50 percent of the wheat content as flour to reduce the size of the particles in the mix did certainly improve the water stability but not the amount of fines in the product
- NQCFA’s water stability and pellet quality trials with various ingredients and die life have resulted in a product that has qualities in these areas that we feel will be acceptable to the industry. Further improvement may be possible in the future in the light of new knowledge.
- The cost as well as the quality has always been a consideration. Farmers agree that a feed of improved performance and quality justifies any reasonable additional cost. The results table show that the most expensive option was not the best and the cost of the new feed has been kept at an acceptable amount.
- The pellets maintained their shape and integrity for a reasonable period, even though they swell and become “rubbery” soon after immersion in water. Previously it was planned to make the juvenile redclaw feed in crumble form to facilitate consumption by small animals. Owing to it becoming “rubbery” it is now believed that feed in standard pellet form would be suitable for juveniles.
- Usage of juvenile feed will be small, as (a) small animals don’t eat much (b) it will only be fed for the first 3 months of growth and (c) will be mostly required only during the summer months. As the mill has a 1 tonne minimum, NQCFA will purchase a tonne which will be for sale at the October 2016 meeting as a service to members. It will be suggested to other branches that they consider adopting this system. Whether this practice is workable long term remains to be assessed.
- On farm assessment of the new feed’s influence on redclaw growth will very likely not show concrete results for some months. The redclaw are showing a marked preference for the new feed over other baits when used in baited traps. Early indications are positive and indicate that the work of JCU will be of great benefit to the industry. Farmers will be asked for feedback at the May 2017 NQCFA meeting.
- Many NQ farmers have been involved in this trial and have displayed patience and willingness to accept the not so successful batches as well as the successful ones as being part of achieving the best possible outcome. Our thanks to them all.
- Throughout the trials, Advanced Rural have displayed an amazing level of co-operation and patience – especially considering the insignificant part redclaw feed plays in their business! Our thanks fellas.
- At the NQCFA meeting on 8th October 2016, the members considered the information in this report and voted in favour of adopting the “Standard” formulation as redclaw feed. While it was acknowledged that the substitution of percentages of flour for wheat did improve the water stability, given the uncertainty of just how long the pellets needed to remain intact, the additional cost was not justified. It was voiced that should further knowledge or developments come to hand from the proposed ‘Tracking Project’ or any other source, this decision could be revisited.
Article in “here’s 10 things to know from QFF” (Queensland Farmers’ Federation), published in September 2016
REDCLAW FARMING ON THE CUSP OF RESURGENCE
On the back of a 10 year research program funded by the Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation and guided by the establishment the industry’s “Operation Kickstart” – a planned program of industry promotion – the redclaw industry is set for a rebuilding phase. Hard lessons have been learnt from the 1990’s boom period, when many people launched themselves into redclaw farming without sufficient forethought, advice, experience, financial backing and knowledge.
New opportunities and knowledge from the results of the Selective Breeding Program, Feed and Nutrition Project and Survival Investigation have injected a series of boosts into the industry over the last five years.
The industry’s informative website – www.queenslandredclaw.org – and the book “Redclaw Farming – Getting Started” were launched in 2013 and a Conference and workshops across the state followed. These initiatives have attracted spirited interest from Queensland, interstate and overseas – sales of the book are vigorous and are indicative of a keen and continuing interest in the industry.
Current farmers, many of whom have been farming successfully since the inception of the industry, are enjoying the prosperity due to the results of research projects and are buoyed by the achievability of profitable sales opportunities. Demand for the product is strong and product quality is excellent. The mass of problems of the early years have been overcome with the acceptance of the fact that redclaw farming is a business like any other. It is not feasible to adopt a hobby style approach and still be successful and profitable.
At this stage all current farms are at a “family business” level, but a Scoping Analysis and Business Plan for large scale farms is in the works. An active State Association incorporating three Branch Associations has the future security and success on the industry firmly in its sights. Involvement with the Federal Government’s North Australia Plan and the Northern Gulf Management Group will result in the development of major farms in the not too distant future.